Beyond the Craft

Order guide / England & Wales

Order of the Secret Monitor

The Order of the Secret Monitor makes brotherly care an organised duty rather than a general aspiration. Its distinctive Visiting Deacon system links ceremony with continuing personal contact between members.

Order of the Secret Monitor emblem

Order of the Secret Monitor or Brotherhood of David and Jonathan. This page distinguishes its documented institutional history, present eligibility and closest alternatives. By Beyond the Craft Editorial Team · Published 13 June 2026 · Last reviewed 20 June 2026 · 7 min read.

Typical themes

Brotherly care, friendship, vigilance and practical support.

Common misconception

The 'Secret Monitor' is not a surveillance role; the title relates to discreet friendship and care.

Good fit if…

You want fellowship and member welfare to be especially visible.

May not be for you if…

You are looking mainly for historical or esoteric study.

A symbolic stone and brass measuring tools on a dark study table
Foundation and formMeasured work, shared discipline and the practical symbolism from which the wider landscape begins.

Documented chronology

  1. The Monitor tradition developed from material associated with the story of David and Jonathan. [1]

  2. An English Grand Council established the modern national system. [1]

  3. Conclaves work the Monitor degrees and provide the qualification route into Scarlet Cord. [1]

Welfare as a defined responsibility

The title refers to discreet warning, loyalty and care within the friendship of David and Jonathan. The Visiting Deacon role gives that principle an organisational form by maintaining contact and awareness rather than leaving welfare entirely informal. The modern English structure belongs to the wider nineteenth-century development of the orders now administered from Mark Masons' Hall. [1] [2]

That emphasis distinguishes OSM from orders whose continuing value rests mainly on historical study or a long degree sequence. The test is whether a Conclave actually sustains the pastoral culture described by the governing body. [1]

Entry and relationship to Scarlet Cord

The public entry foundation is a subscribing Master Mason in good standing. OSM does not generally require Royal Arch or Mark, making it one of the more direct routes from Craft under the current English structure. [1]

Scarlet Cord is a separate order for which Monitor membership supplies the qualification. It should not be described as automatically included with a Conclave subscription or as a compulsory completion of OSM. [1] [3]

Conclave life

Conclaves combine ceremonial work, administration and fellowship, but the welfare system creates obligations between meetings. A candidate should ask how Visiting Deacons operate locally and whether the role is active in practice rather than merely part of the ritual language. [1]

Dates, dining, subscription and regalia remain local questions. The relevant commitment is not only attendance but willingness to notice absence, maintain contact and support members consistently. [1]

Who may value it

OSM is a strong fit for a Master Mason who values friendship expressed through practical care and wants an order available without accumulating several prior memberships. It is less suited to someone whose chief aim is esoteric research or chivalric spectacle.

Compare it with Craft welfare work honestly. A well-run Lodge may already provide excellent pastoral support; OSM's distinction is making that concern central to the identity and offices of a separate order.

Key distinction

It can be entered from Craft and is centred on welfare and friendship; it is not a surveillance role, research society or preliminary rank of the Royal Arch.

Frequently asked questions

What most distinguishes Order of the Secret Monitor?

It can be entered from Craft and is centred on welfare and friendship; it is not a surveillance role, research society or preliminary rank of the Royal Arch.

Who can join Order of the Secret Monitor?

The published starting point is Subscribing Master Mason in good standing. Check the dated official eligibility source below because national and local procedures can change.

What happens at meetings of Order of the Secret Monitor?

Public information describes this pattern: Conclaves typically meet a few times each year. The Visiting Deacon system adds an ongoing welfare responsibility beyond ceremonies. A recent local programme remains the best evidence of the continuing experience.

What should I compare with Order of the Secret Monitor?

Begin with Craft Freemasonry and Scarlet Cord. Compare purpose, eligibility, governance and ordinary participation rather than rank.

Sources and further reading
  1. Mark Masons' Hall: Order of the Secret Monitor ↗Order of the Secret Monitor · Official organisational source · Retrieved 20 June 2026 · Supports: history, eligibility, purpose.
  2. Mark Masons' Hall: history ↗Mark Masons' Hall · Official organisational source · Retrieved 20 June 2026 · Supports: history, governance.
  3. Mark Masons' Hall: Order of the Scarlet Cord ↗Order of the Scarlet Cord · Official organisational source · Retrieved 20 June 2026 · Supports: relationships, progression.